BRT: think service, not mode *

The buzzword “BRT” covers a lot of different services. A comparison, with some notes on what it means to a rider:

type local bus BRT “lite” full BRT light rail
example Houston 2 Bellaire Los Angeles Rapid Cleveland Euclid Corridor Houston METRORail
stations with shelters and seating sometimes yes yes yes
Shelters = a place to sit in the shade and out of the rain while you wait.
ticket machines at stations no no yes yes
Ticket machines = you can board at any door and you won’t be held up while somebody fumbles for change.
simple routes and distinctive vehicles no yes yes yes
Simple routes = you know you’re getting on the right bus without having to remember numbers.
traffic light priority no yes yes yes
Traffic light priority = you get there faster.
reserved lanes no no yes yes
Reserved lanes = you’ll be at your destination in the same time at nay time of day, regardless of traffic.
frequency of service irregular 5-15 min. 5-15 min. 5-15 min.
Frequent service = you can show up at the stop without checking a schedule and you’ll be on your way soon.

By no stretch of the imagination is “BRT lite” a light rail equivalent service. Full BRT is pretty close, though (light rail still has higher capacity and a smoother ride). The question is: when politicians or transit agencies say BRT, what do they mean?

The difference is in the details, and the kind of service we get will be determined by decisions made as design progresses. An agency may compromise in response to budget and community concerns, or they may hold firm to the goal of light rail equivalent service. For example, residents are often worried both about traffic impacts from removing car lanes and impact on houses from widening the street. An agency might respond by having busses and cars share a lane, pleasing some residents but delivering an inferior transit system. Another instance: light rail can’t cross railroad lines at grade, but BRT can. Does an agency save money by keeping crossings at grade, leaving busses stuck behind crossing gates?

Fundamentally, few people care about bus vs. rail. That’s a debate for politicians and transportation geeks. What riders care about is how soon their ride gets there, how comfortable it is, and how quickly they will get where they are going. That’s the bottom line, and that’s how any BRT plan should be judged.

Comments are Disabled